Yobe senatorial ticket: Court dismisses suit seeking to sack Ahmad Lawan

News

Federal High Court in Abuja on Tuesday dismissed a suit seeking to void the emergence of former Senate President, Ahmad Lawan, as All Progressives Congress (APC)’s candidate for the Yobe North Senatorial District of Yobe.

Justice Salim Ibrahim, in judgment, held that the suit was statute-barred and not justiciable, thereby depriving the court of the requisite jurisdiction to entertain the matter.

The judge held that the plaintiff, Hassan Kafayos, failed to place credible evidence before the court to substantiate his claim that he was actually excluded from the exercise.

According to him, the court is bound by the evidence placed before it.

Justice Ibrahim, who upheld the preliminary objection filed by the defence, said the plaintiff was not entitled to the reliefs soughts.

The judge observed that though Kafayos placed heavy reliance on the Supreme Court’s decision on Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) against Sule Lamido’s case, he held that there was no justification for extending the principles established in the apex court’s decision to the circumstances of the instant case.

He said the circumstances of the two cases were fundamentally different.

The judge stated that “judicial decisions must be considered within the context of their peculiar facts and circumstances.”

He stressed that a judgment is an authority only for what it actually decides and cannot be applied indiscriminately to other cases.

According to the judge, the Supreme Court in the Lamido case dealt with an alleged violation of rights and the statutory oversight responsibilities of the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) over political parties under the Electoral Act.

He, however, said that the instant suit was strictly concerned with the plaintiff’s allegation of being denied participation in a primary election after purportedly satisfying the 1st respondent’s internal requirements.

The judge maintained that the case did not involve the alleged interference with or violation of constitutional provisions in the manner established in the Lamido decision.

In the final analysis, the judge held that the plaintiff had failed to establish entitlement to any of the statutory or constitutional reliefs sought.

He, consequently, dismissed the originating summons filed by Kafayos on May 29 for being incompetent and lacking merit.

Kafayos, in the originating summons filed by Mgboh, had sued APC, Prof. Nentawe Yilwatda, APC’s National Chairman; Lawan and INEC as 1st to 4th defendants respectively.

The plaintiff, an aggrieved aspirant in the May 18 Yobe North Senatorial District primary election, prayed the court to void the emergence of Lawan, the former Senate President, as party’s candidate for the 2027 poll.

Kafayos, in the suit, sought four reliefs.

He sought a declaration that the deliberate exclusion or suppression of his lawful participation, a financial member of APC, as aspirant in the May 18 senatorial election by the 1st and 2nd defendants without any reasonable cause, breached his right of freedom from discrimination.

He said this is guaranteed by Section 42 of the 1999 Constitution.

He said the defendants’ action breached Sections 84, 85, 86 and 87 of the Electoral Act, 2026 and also violated the party’s guidelines as provided for in Articles 2, 9.3 and 20 of the APC’s constitution not to undermine democratic procedures or principle in the internal affairs of the party.

The claimant, therefore, sought an order of injunction restraining APC and Yilwatda from forwarding Lawan’s name to INEC as consensus candidate of the party to have been lawfully nominated as candidate for Yobe North Senatorial District.

He also sought an order restraining INEC from accepting or publishing Lawan’s name “over the flawed primary election of the 1st defendant for Yobe North Senatorial District primary election that took place on the 18th of May, 2026,” among others.

But Lawan, APC and Yilwatda urged the court to dismiss the suit in their separate processes.

Lawan, in his preliminary objection, challenged the jurisdiction of the court to hear the suit, urging the court to dismiss it for want of jurisdiction.

The APC also corroborated Lawan’s argument in a preliminary objection filed by Adedayo Adedeji, SAN.

Adedeji prayed the court to dismiss the suit for being fundamentally defective and for vesting no jurisdiction on the court.

He equally argued that the suit is statute-barred as it was filed outside the mandatory 14-day period prescribed by Section 285(14) of the 1999 Constitution (as amended) and Rule 9 of the Practice Directions, 2022.

The senior lawyer adopted his processes and prayed the court to dismiss Kafayos’ suit with a substantial cost.

Adedeji described the suit as an abuse of court process, arguing that the suit ought not to be filed by the plaintiff.

“The court has no jurisdiction because the suit is statute barred, having been filed outside the time frame prescribed by the constitution,” he said.

He observed that the primary was held in May while the suit was filed long after the time.

Adedeji also urged the court to discountenance with the document in which questions for cross examination of subpoenaed witnesses were compiled, describing it as incompetent.

Yilwatda, in his counter affidavit deposed to by Lovelyn Donatus, a legal officer in the Legal Services Department of APC, averred that the party duly constituted the Primary Election Committee that conducted the Senatorial poll.

Leave a Reply